Our Story
A hometown candy shop built by Kristin and Matt Koester — named for Fostoria itself.
“It’s not just about candy. It’s about bringing people together and reminding them that joy still lives right here in our hometown.”Kristin VanCuren Koester, owner
A childhood dream, opened with joy
Kristin’s idea began with a simple thought: “We need something in town for kids, a candy store!” After years of working with preschoolers, she and her husband Matt turned that wish into a shop on South Main Street.
“But we opened a candy store. We expect joy and excitement. That’s what this place is for.”Kristin VanCuren Koester, owner
Why “Calico Charlie’s”?
The name honors Charles Foster, Fostoria’s namesake and a former governor of Ohio, whose nickname was “Calico Charlie.” Kristin embraced the story for its colorful spirit.
Pieces of Fostoria inside
The shop itself carries local history: shelving from a long-closed hardware store, chandeliers from the church Kristin grew up attending, and a cart from an old five-and-dime — donated or discovered by locals who recognized the care behind Calico Charlie’s.
Plan Your Visit
206 S. Main St., Fostoria, OH 44830